Martial Arts/Combat Training/Stat Rolls Suggestion

[JotunnLord]

IGN: JotunnLord
DATE:10/1/2022
WHAT YOU WANT TO SUGGEST OR MENTION: I believe that a combat training or martial arts system would be a cool thing to add to add that or a stat system similar to D&D where depending on what you are doing you may gain a bonus such as Dodging would be a bonus to your roll to avoid/block an attack and Strength would help you attack and Constitution may increase how many hits you can take and what not
HOW WILL THIS BENEFIT THE SERVER/COMMUNITY?: How does it make sense for an average person with no past history of fighting have an equal chance to win a fight with a criminal who has been doing this for years or even just a regular athlete who should be naturally better but is down graded to having to be equal in strength even though it makes no sense so please consider this request

 

[Kana]

-1

You have the ability to P2L if you do not like the rolling system (with the consent of another player). This suggestion will only complicate RP scenarios, and while I'd love to compare SRP to the (mostly) peaceful D&D community, it is a pool of arguing, toxicity, and bad behavior when it comes to combat situations.

 

[Iris.fi]

-1 literally just makes it overcomplicated. As Kana said, P2L is an option

 

[moved2paws2]

NEUTRAL/-1

As Kana said, while it's really interesting: It can easily be abused by GangRPers, as someone who's done P2L alot, being fair is hard when you can apply to be over 6'5 and will most likely cause a spike in people applying for less common heights unfortunately :(!
As someone who does have a 7'4" character, it is interesting to see how his height would affect his combat, but unfortunately this system is easily abused.

{Also! Remember to double check your format! Accidently leaving it bold makes it a little harder to read and could lead to your future applications getting denied <3}

 

[- - -]

+1
Wouldnt relay that much on luck anymore but more on Skill

 

[cho0ii]

-1
P2L is a thing

 

[philbertman42]

SRP will likely never have a more complex or realistic system of combat, because everyone is used to the way things currently are. RPG type statistics would be way more interesting and realistic than complete RNG, but it's not going to happen.

 

[Latte]

Familiar suggestion

 

[JotunnLord]

I believe that you folks are thinking I am saying that we do the calculations or that stats are the main way I was saying what I mainly meant is make it is that at a certain amount of fights or shrine training you would get a bonus to the roll automatically instead of having to do the math yourself which would be stupid and the bonus that I am thinking isn't all that have like 2 tiers maybe 1 being a +25 bonus and tier 2 have a +50 bonus it's not much different than the age stuff and it would make gangrp and self-defense a bit more feasible for people rping as adults plus making it more realistic sure there would be those who are rping college or highschool and get the bonus but its not like it would be major enough to make enough of a impact to be game breaking nor something that has any rules that gangrpers can manipulate sorry for not being specific enough I had written the original at like 3 and I was a bit tired but I felt I should put it out while I had the idea in my head

 

[Arocatula]

-1

 

[Nylu]

-1

Overcomplicated

 

[DarkEclipic]

-1

 

[FadedMoonlight]

it is a pool of arguing, toxicity, and bad behavior when it comes to combat situations.

Didn't know we were allowed to speak such brutal honesty. But as much as I'd like to say that this community is great, Kana is completely right.

-1

 

[RexLobo]

-1

 

[JotunnLord]

Didn't know we were allowed to speak such brutal honesty. But as much as I'd like to say that this community is great, Kana is completely right.

-1

It is true most of the gangrpers who primarily play combat are toxic who use the rules by the letter in order to essentially auto win no questions asked which I find very infuriating as someone who believes that the system is fine with people who are more lenient and yknow just nice people but you'll have that one jerk always who goes "Um actually that is not correct accodring to secition 9.8 C of the rules document failrp L"

 

[BearDucky]

-1

Personally I think no.

 

[robinzee]

-1

You have the ability to P2L if you do not like the rolling system (with the consent of another player). This suggestion will only complicate RP scenarios, and while I'd love to compare SRP to the (mostly) peaceful D&D community, it is a pool of arguing, toxicity, and bad behavior when it comes to combat situations.

I second Kana’s thoughts on this. Also, in D&D and other TTRPGs like it, there is always the looming presence of the Game Master acting as an invisible referee and rules guide to the players, something which isn’t always possible on SchoolRP, if at all.

Thank you for making this suggestion.

 

[Ghostfire]

-1

P2L

 

[JotunnLord]

I would like to note for all the people who are saying "Well you can just get realism through p2l" tell me if you are in a fight are you gonna wanna p2l no thats boring for everyone involved and no one in there right mind would choose that this whole idea is for realism in real life while sure its highly improbable to beat a martial artist as an average joe it is completely possible for it to happen no one wants to p2l but I'm sure there are alot more people who are sick and tired of having there character who just doesn't gangrp being beaten up by some average guy with a bat or brass knuckles

While I am typing I would like to comment on the DM always watching and it being a requirement thing once more the stat thing if this were to be implemented would hopefully be coded into the rolling plugin or if your approved by the admins you just get a little item that proves you do have said stats or training a DM would not be needed if its just a implemented system and I am not saying we add more attacks or what not because it is a big leap to say oh you get a slight bonus for then the whole server requires what is essentially a mod to what over every single combat

 

[Ghostfire]

I would like to note for all the people who are saying "Well you can just get realism through p2l" tell me if you are in a fight are you gonna wanna p2l no thats boring for everyone involved and no one in there right mind would choose that this whole idea is for realism in real life while sure its highly improbable to beat a martial artist as an average joe it is completely possible for it to happen no one wants to p2l but I'm sure there are alot more people who are sick and tired of having there character who just doesn't gangrp being beaten up by some average guy with a bat or brass knuckles

While I am typing I would like to comment on the DM always watching and it being a requirement thing once more the stat thing if this were to be implemented would hopefully be coded into the rolling plugin or if your approved by the admins you just get a little item that proves you do have said stats or training a DM would not be needed if its just a implemented system and I am not saying we add more attacks or what not because it is a big leap to say oh you get a slight bonus for then the whole server requires what is essentially a mod to what over every single combat

P2L literally portrays realistic fighting based on your character's abilities

If you want your character to have an 'edge' over another opponent just learn fighting styles yourself and roleplay them out. The point of roleplay and P2L is to portray what your character can realistically do