This thread isn't an argument about GangRP or about if eyes should be allowed to be taken.. This is a suggestion to fix an arbitrary rule that really makes no sense
mc.roleplayhub.com
players online
Greater realism in GangRP
- Thread starter DivineCaesar
- Start date
- Status
This thread isn't an argument about GangRP or about if eyes should be allowed to be taken.. This is a suggestion to fix an arbitrary rule that really makes no sense
depends where you live tbh, last month a worker at my subway got a dudes mayo order wrong n’ he killed him. Earlier this week some other kid died over petty stuff man. People have fragile egos, but Karakura shouldn’t be that wild or central city like since it’s in the middle of no where
Last edited:
royyyy
Level 2
+1
While I do agree with what's being said about getting knocked out, it does not make sense that you are knocked out in a petty brawl and you decide to take a whole appendage, maybe if Major permissions were changed a small bit such as threatening with a weapon or a gang assault giving major perms I do believe a Pocket Knife and Nagi should have the ability to take eyes due to the fact that they are still bladed weapons and not being able to take them is almost most bladed weapons useless as a Nagi nor PK can't take limbs period so really only the tongue could be taken if you wish to majorly assault someone, making it so only Katana's can do so is just needlessly complicating things for GangRPers, especially Non VGM's and to respond to 'just don't take eyes out' sounds like an attempt to just disregard gangrper's opinions/suggestions as sometimes taking eyes has a personal icly reason to i.e a witness. If you don't want situations to escalate do not get yourself into them i.e antagonizing a fight or getting involved in criminal activity either as a bystander or opposition
While I do agree with what's being said about getting knocked out, it does not make sense that you are knocked out in a petty brawl and you decide to take a whole appendage, maybe if Major permissions were changed a small bit such as threatening with a weapon or a gang assault giving major perms I do believe a Pocket Knife and Nagi should have the ability to take eyes due to the fact that they are still bladed weapons and not being able to take them is almost most bladed weapons useless as a Nagi nor PK can't take limbs period so really only the tongue could be taken if you wish to majorly assault someone, making it so only Katana's can do so is just needlessly complicating things for GangRPers, especially Non VGM's and to respond to 'just don't take eyes out' sounds like an attempt to just disregard gangrper's opinions/suggestions as sometimes taking eyes has a personal icly reason to i.e a witness. If you don't want situations to escalate do not get yourself into them i.e antagonizing a fight or getting involved in criminal activity either as a bystander or opposition
wowwwww ;(
Neutral
I don't see why those objects wouldn't be able to take an eye but like Kana, Ghost, and Mike have said, I don't see the reason why you want to take eyes so bad. If we're talking realism, people aren't just randomly taking limbs just because you got knocked out by them. Just as Kana said, good writing over realism. Realism is great and all but when it comes to getting in the way with actual roleplay and good writing, it doesn't need to be realistic. I put believability and good writing over realism anyday.
I don't see why those objects wouldn't be able to take an eye but like Kana, Ghost, and Mike have said, I don't see the reason why you want to take eyes so bad. If we're talking realism, people aren't just randomly taking limbs just because you got knocked out by them. Just as Kana said, good writing over realism. Realism is great and all but when it comes to getting in the way with actual roleplay and good writing, it doesn't need to be realistic. I put believability and good writing over realism anyday.
This is not a valid argument against (what I think to be) valid criticism, some of it being from actual figures in the gang roleplay scene, one of them literally being Mike.
stop crying about your original character's legs being cut off. you shouldn’t be GANGRPING if you don’t want your character to get hurt or killed. or maybe just get better at gangrp? get better rolls. i don’t do p2l because there’s no RISK to it LOL. why would i p2l anyway? that’s just you trying to excuse your stalling. what the hell is a d slur? i’m getting staff, by the way. atoki is my favorite staff uwu. what do you mean my character doesn’t have a reason to do this? you knocked me out. what’s the difference between JockRP and GangRP? stop making stuff up. i have perms. i don’t want to waste them. talk to staff after this if you want to get it voided. like i said, just get better rolls and stop doing p2l. there’s no point anyway. no risk and no reward. plus i’m too lazy to type actions. cuultist is my favorite bmd btw, invest in a nagitana.
Sorry I shouldn’t have said that I apologise if I came off as rude-
The reason behind it is that gangrpers have found a way AROUND kps now that they know blinding a character results in that character being blind
heb's kps rule did not help much
-1
SapouT
Level 21
There is actually not much to discuss yk, a knife is capable of removing items, thats how stuff works like? It aint hard for a sharp pointy object to remove an eye
I know the general reason, I just find it very lackluster in the terms or actual roleplay.
I don't Gang-Roleplay at all but I'm here to say that this claim is not true, people kill each other, take away limbs and etc in real over dumb stuff, it honestly depends on where you live, Karakura is a high crime rate Town or City, just like some gang-roleplayers say, high-risk high reward if your character gets blinded then you'll need to learn how to roleplay as such, maybe you'll learn to love roleplay as a blind gangster
I think logic should work with roleplay, to have good writing realism and logic should also be included
Another 'I didn't read the suggestion, -1 because gangrp bad grrr' vote ..
No... maybe occasionally, depending on the person, but fights happen literally all the time IRL. I've seen a million of them, but never have I EVER seen someone come back and take their limbs afterward...... I live near a crime-ridden area as well, but even disregarding realism, narratively it is the furthest thing from interesting. This is a roleplay server, not a game to disable each other's characters, that may be fun for some... but not the receiving end. Roleplay is about cooperation, and good writing, not perms or realism. Do you think realism exists in FantasyRP? It is not the focus of this server, instead, believability in writing should be the main focus... There is a clear crime lore, gang roleplayers should follow it to better roleplay their characters in a city like Karakura. These restrictions exist for purpose of doing this. I've advocated for realism many times, but good writing is ALWAYS more important.
Didn't see this before, I have been in the gangrp community for years... I'm very much not anti-gangrp. I simply promote good writing over realism.
Lizalopod
Level 130
Please remain respectful.
- Status