mc.roleplayhub.com

players online

INSTRUMENT SYSTEM REWORK | An idea to make the system better!

findouticly

Level 47
findouticly
findouticly
Omega
WHAT'S YOUR MINECRAFT USERNAME?:
findouticly
WHAT'S THE TITLE OF YOUR SUGGESTION?:
INSTRUMENT SYSTEM REWORK | An idea to make the system better!

WHAT'S YOUR SUGGESTION?:
You know how you can't actually make any music with the instruments, or if you can, you have to basically memorize the pattern? Well, after reading @Tippie 's feedback on the quieten the obnoxiously loud instruments suggestion, I've decided to make a suggestion about upgrading the instrument system, a complete rework of it!

THE IDEA:

After thinking for some time, I've came up with an idea. You know how the school planner works? Well, how I imagine the instrumen to work, is that a menu similar to the planner pops up, but with the notes which you want to play!

HOW IT WOULD WORK:

You could either choose to play the notes as soon as you click them;

or you could click them in an order, and then after clicking a finish button, the notes would play in this order!


Of course you can choose the delay between every note. The first one sounds more do-able, but I believe that the developers could be able to do the second one, but it surely would be harder to do...

HOW IT WOULD LOOK:

I didn't have a lot of free time, so i quickly made something in paint.net
1727778391918.png

Basically, something like that or smaller would show up on a menu, and it'd of course have the note, which you want to play, written on it!

HOW WILL THIS BENEFIT THE COMMUNITY?:
This of course could make the instruments sound more realistic and make it sound like an actual song, instead of hearing people spam one note to annoy people. I believe this could also bring some immersion into SRP, as you could hear people play beautiful songs when walking across the Karakura streets!​
 
Last edited:

2500

Level 5
2500
2500
Rich+
is that a menu similar to the planner pops up, but with the notes which you want to play!
You could either choose to play the notes as soon as you click them;

or you could click them in an order, and then after clicking a finish button, the notes would play in this order!
the real-time option is going to be a pain to use for anyone with high ping, or any ping for that matter

the ordered one seems cool, but nobody is going to take the time to actually compose proper music. people would just make jumbled messes, worsening the spam issue.
instead of hearing people spam one note to annoy people.
newer, curious or annoying players are going to spam regardless. even with this system it would be no different. the simplicity of the current system makes it so accessible

its not worth the development time, -1 from me
 

findouticly

Level 47
findouticly
findouticly
Omega
Thread starter
newer, curious or annoying players are going to spam regardless. even with this system it would be no different. the simplicity of the current system makes it so accessible
This could easily be avoided with a cooldown tho? Like a few seconds before making an another song!
the real-time option is going to be a pain to use for anyone with high ping, or any ping for that matter
That's what I thought about as well, and I think that is why the second option is better.
 

kustomzero

Level 151
UrAJinx
UrAJinx
Omega
This would be amazing because then we could actually play our own songs from artists we like or even our own original music. +1 if possible
 

frenzyyy

Level 19
Community Team
Media Team
frenzyyy
frenzyyy
Omega+
+1

I really like this idea! I am more drawn towards the second one because of what was said above, it would be a really fun addition and could introduce even more possibilities by reworking the system. For example, we could have a school band, we could even get performers up on stage and hold shows every once in a while (my Theatre Kid is coming out!)
 

-kam

Level 107
x4kam
x4kam
Notable
+1

A good plugin, would be fun to use. However there may be latency issues with the hitting of the note and the note happening, but it sounds like a good concept!
 

KimiNoUso

Level 352
Owner
HS Sports Lead
Developer
KimiNoUso
KimiNoUso
Omega+
Reviewed
Thank you for your suggestion!

- We're waiting on some new sounds to replace the existing guitar ones which are quite loud in-game.​
- As for adding guis and other things to instruments, its definitely a cool idea which we'll consider adding once we've fixed the bugs we're already working on.​
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top